GroceriesReview.co.uk provides independent reviews and recommendations. Some pages contain affiliate links to Amazon.co.uk, and we may earn a commission when you make a qualifying purchase at no extra cost to you.
Pickled onions are a classic UK cupboard staple, sharp, crunchy, and ideal with cheese, pies, or cold cuts.
The main choice is vinegar style and sweetness level, which determines whether they’re punchy and traditional or milder and snackable.
🧅 Quick Picks (Decision Shortcuts)
- Best overall: Garner’s Original Pickled Onions
- Best budget: Essential Waitrose Pickled Onions
- Best for ploughman’s: Opies Cocktail Onions
- Best ‘cleaner ingredient’ style: Baxters Silverskin Onions (simpler profiles where available)
How we judged these (criteria-first)
- Crunch & texture – firm bite without softness.
- Vinegar base – malt vinegar (rounded, traditional) vs spirit vinegar (sharper).
- Sweetness level – from sharp to sweet-and-sour.
- Onion size – silverskin (small, mild) vs larger onions (stronger flavour).
- Flavour balance – acidity vs sweetness vs onion strength.
- Versatility – works with cheese, pies, salads, or snacking.
- Jar size & value – single jars vs multipacks.
Ranked picks
1) Garner’s Original Pickled Onions
Best for: Traditional ploughman’s and cheese boards
Why it’s good
- Strong malt vinegar tang gives classic British flavour.
- Firm texture delivers a proper crunch.
- Balanced sharpness cuts through rich cheeses and meats.
Trade-off
- Quite sharp; may be too intense for casual snacking.
How to use
- Serve with cheddar and bread.
- Add to cold meat platters.
Substitution
- Any malt vinegar pickled onions.
2) Baxters Silverskin Pickled Onions
Best for: Milder, snackable onions
Why it’s good
- Smaller onions give a gentler flavour.
- Slight sweetness makes them easier to eat on their own.
- Consistent size works well in salads or lunchboxes.
Trade-off
- Less punch than traditional larger pickled onions.
How to use
- Toss into salads.
- Serve as a side with cold cuts.
Substitution
- Look for “silverskin onions” on the label.
3) Opies Cocktail Onions
Best for: Drinks, platters, and light snacking
Why it’s good
- Small size makes them easy to portion.
- Clean vinegar flavour works in multiple uses.
- Reliable texture with good crunch.
Trade-off
- Milder flavour; less impact in a ploughman’s.
How to use
- Add to snack boards.
- Use as a garnish for savoury drinks.
Substitution
- Any cocktail or small pickled onions.
4) Essential Waitrose Pickled Onions
Best for: Budget everyday use
Why it’s good
- Good balance of sharpness and sweetness for the price.
- Suitable for regular sandwiches and sides.
- Widely available in-store.
Trade-off
- Less distinctive flavour than premium brands.
How to use
- Add to sandwiches or salads.
- Serve alongside pies.
Substitution
- Any supermarket own-brand pickled onions.
5) Opies Cornichons & Onions
Best for: Mixed pickle lovers and variety
Why it’s good
- Combines onions with gherkins for varied texture and flavour.
- Works well on cheese boards.
- Adds visual and taste contrast.
Trade-off
- Less focused if you want only onions.
How to use
- Serve as part of a ploughman’s.
- Add to grazing boards.
Substitution
- Any mixed pickle jar with onions.
How to choose (by shopper type)
- For traditional flavour: Go for malt vinegar onions → sharper, classic taste.
- For snacking: Choose silverskin onions → milder and easier to eat.
- For entertaining: Pick cocktail or mixed jars → better presentation and variety.
- For everyday use: A balanced supermarket jar works well.
Availability & practical swaps
- Pickled onions are widely available across UK supermarkets in multiple sizes.
- Multipacks and specialty jars are more common online.
- If your preferred option isn’t available, match by:
- Onion size (silverskin vs larger)
- Vinegar type (malt vs spirit)
FAQs
What’s the difference between silverskin and regular pickled onions?
Silverskin onions are smaller and milder, while larger onions have a stronger, sharper flavour.
Which pickled onions are best for a ploughman’s?
Malt vinegar pickled onions for a traditional pairing with cheese.
Are pickled onions very strong?
It depends, some are sharp and punchy, others are milder and slightly sweet.
Do I need to refrigerate after opening?
Yes, most jars recommend refrigeration after opening.
What should I check on the label?
Look for vinegar type, sugar level, and onion size.
Conclusion
For most UK shoppers, Garner’s Original Pickled Onions is the safest all-round choice, proper crunch, classic malt vinegar flavour, and strong pairing with everyday foods. If you prefer something milder, silverskin onions are the easiest switch. Focus on vinegar style and onion size, and you’ll quickly land on the right jar for your cupboard.