GroceriesReview.co.uk provides independent reviews and recommendations. Some pages contain affiliate links to Amazon.co.uk, and we may earn a commission when you make a qualifying purchase at no extra cost to you.
Sweet pickles (often labelled sweet gherkins or sweet & sour cucumbers in the UK) are all about balance, a touch of sugar softens the acidity, making them easier to snack on and more versatile in sandwiches.
The key is choosing the right level of sweetness so they complement, rather than overpower, your food.
🥒 Quick Picks (Decision Shortcuts)
- Best overall: Mrs Elswood Sandwich Gherkins
- Best budget: Kühne Pickled Gherkins multipacks
- Best for burgers: Dino’s Pickles stackers
- Best ‘cleaner ingredient’ style: Biona Organic sweet gherkins (shorter ingredient lists where available)
How we judged these (criteria-first)
- Sweetness balance – enough sugar to mellow acidity without becoming cloying.
- Crunch – retains firmness after opening.
- Pickling base – vinegar type + sugar level affects sharpness.
- Cut & format – whole, sliced, or spears for different uses.
- Ingredient simplicity – shorter lists often give cleaner flavour.
- Versatility – works in burgers, lunchboxes, or on their own.
- Value & pack size – multipacks vs single jars.
Ranked picks
1) Mrs Elswood Sandwich Gherkins
Best for: Everyday use (sandwiches, wraps, lunchboxes)
Why it’s good
- Balanced sweet-tangy profile suits most tastes.
- Consistent size and crunch for easy slicing.
- Common in UK supermarkets → easy repeat buy.
Trade-off
- Slight sweetness means less sharpness than dill-only pickles.
How to use
- Slice into sandwiches or toasties.
- Add to lunchboxes for a mild, snackable pickle.
Substitution
- Any “sandwich gherkins” or mild sweet gherkins.
2) Dino’s American Style Sweet Pickles (Stackers)
Best for: Burgers and hot dogs
Why it’s good
- Pre-sliced “stackers” give perfect burger layering.
- Sweeter profile complements rich meats and cheese.
- Designed for fast, no-prep meals.
Trade-off
- Less flexible for recipes needing whole or chopped gherkins.
How to use
- Layer directly into burgers.
- Add to hot dogs or wraps.
Substitution
- Look for “burger pickles” or “sweet pickle slices.”
3) Kühne Sweet & Sour Gherkins (Multipack)
Best for: Value and regular use
Why it’s good
- Reliable sweet-sour balance across jars.
- Multipacks offer better value per jar.
- Versatile for sandwiches, salads, and sides.
Trade-off
- Slightly softer crunch than premium or small-batch options.
How to use
- Slice into potato salad.
- Serve alongside cold meats.
Substitution
- Any continental sweet-sour gherkins.
4) Melis Pickled Gherkins (Sweet-leaning)
Best for: Larger jars with a fuller sweet profile
Why it’s good
- Generous jar size suits families or frequent use.
- Noticeable sweetness gives a rounder flavour.
- Good for sharing boards or sides.
Trade-off
- Sweetness may overpower delicate dishes.
How to use
- Serve with grilled meats.
- Chop into salads for contrast.
Substitution
- Any larger-format sweet gherkin jar.
5) Sweet Dill Gherkins (Fermented-style options)
Best for: More complex flavour (sweet + tang + slight funk)
Why it’s good
- Combines dill freshness with mild sweetness.
- Often more complex flavour profile.
- Appeals to those who want less processed taste.
Trade-off
- Less widely available; often pricier.
How to use
- Serve as a snack.
- Pair with cheese or grain salads.
Substitution
- Any sweet dill or lightly fermented pickles.
How to choose (by shopper type)
- For burgers & fast food at home: Go for pre-sliced sweet pickles → convenience + consistency.
- For everyday sandwiches: Choose balanced sweet gherkins → versatile and widely liked.
- For snacking: Pick slightly sweeter jars → easier to eat on their own.
- For less sweetness: Look for “sweet & sour” rather than “sweet” on labels.
Availability & practical swaps
- Sweet pickles are widely available in UK supermarkets, often labelled sweet gherkins or sweet & sour cucumbers.
- Multipacks and American-style slices are more common online.
- If your preferred brand isn’t available, match by:
- Sweetness level (sweet vs sweet & sour)
- Cut (whole vs sliced vs spears)
FAQs
What’s the difference between sweet pickles and gherkins?
Sweet pickles are gherkins with added sugar, giving a milder, rounder taste.
Are sweet pickles good for burgers?
Yes, sweetness balances salty, rich fillings like beef and cheese.
Do all sweet pickles taste the same?
No, some lean very sweet, others are sweet & sour with more tang.
Which size jar should I buy?
Small jars for occasional use; multipacks or large jars for regular sandwiches.
What should I check on the label?
Look at sugar content, vinegar type, and cut style.
Conclusion
For most UK shoppers, Mrs Elswood Sandwich Gherkins is the safest all-round sweet pickle, balanced, easy to use, and widely available. If you want stronger sweetness, go for American-style slices, while sweet & sour continental jars offer a more restrained option. Focus on sweetness level, cut, and jar size, and you’ll land on the right jar quickly.